Votes and Vulnerabilities: Technology, Security, and Future of Electronic Voting

     In this election season, Mesoteryx is not wading into politics. Politics is not our charter.  On the other hand, discussing voting technology, as politically “thorny” as it is nowadays, is worth the risk.  It’s the hidden machinery between us and the election outcomes that have great impact on our lives.

    The United States’ first national election took place from December 15, 1788, to January 7, 1789, a year after the Constitution was ratified (American History Central, 2025). It made a reluctant George Washington the first U.S. president. Since then, the process of voting, at least in principle, has not changed: a voter casts a vote for the candidate of their choice for each office listed on a ballot. What has changed is who is eligible to vote, the condition of the ballot, and how votes are tallied and the results secured.

    Males with American citizenship have exercised the right to vote in national, state, and local elections since the republic was founded. The size of the electorate grew dramatically when women won the right to vote with ratification of the 19th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution in 1920. From the presidential election of 1789 and into the first decades of the 19th century, the electorate voted with hand-written paper ballots. In addition to errors, omissions, and inconsistencies, the paper ballot system exposed a voter’s choices to onlookers. In highly consequential elections, this opened the door to votes cast for undesirable candidates under fear of retribution from political operatives. To address these problems, states adopted the secret ballot (a.k.a. the Australian ballot), beginning with Massachusetts in 1888 (LegalClarity, 2025).  The secret ballot has three far-reaching principles. First, a secret ballot fosters privacy. Votes are cast in an enclosed booth or secluded area that prevents eavesdroppers from observing the voter’s choices. Secret ballot privacy is a central feature of modern electronic voting technology. The second principle of the secret ballot is anonymity. No one knows who cast a particular vote. The third principle is standardization. Secret ballots in the U.S. are printed and distributed by the government. They are uniform in appearance and content and list all eligible candidates for offices from all political parties. At the dawn of the 20th century, two factors catalyzed changes to how votes are tallied and secured. The first is expansion of the population of eligible voters with ratification of the 19th Amendment. The second relates to the size of the secret ballot. The MIT Election Data and Science Laboratory describes ballot size this way:

The U.S. has the longest ballots in the democratic world, which is both the result of federalism (with three levels of officials to be elected) and the distrust in the U.S. of appointed officials, which has increased the number of elected offices on ballots (MIT Election Data and Science Laboratory, 2023).

These factors led to an untenable workload for election officials charged with tallying hundreds of thousands or even millions of votes in densely populated districts. In the late 19th century, automatic vote counting became essential to unambiguously determine the outcome of an election within days and not weeks, as the public expects. The stage was set for the first voting machines designed for the principles of the secret ballot.

    The earliest known U.S. patent for an Electrographic Vote-Recorder (EVR) is credited to Thomas Alva Edison, granted on June 1, 1869, (Henry Ford Museum of American Innovation, 2025). The Henry Ford Museum’s exhibit of Edison’s EVR is pictured below, in addition to the patent drawing. Edison designed the EVR with legislative voting in mind, and although it was never mass-produced


Top: U.S. Patent No. 90,646, titled the “Electrographic Vote-Recorder,” was Edison’s first patent (Source: Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons), Bottom: The Henry Ford Museum's exhibit of the Edison EVR (Source: Henry Ford Museum of American Innovation)

for use in general elections, it reflects the thinking of 19th century innovators in response to the growing need for election automation due to the factors discussed above (Reich, 2016). As the photo shows, the EVR comprises a drum with attached typewriter characters corresponding each legislator’s “yes” or “no” vote. The drum interfaces with wheels that count the yeah or nay votes. This portion of the EVR resided at a clerk’s desk (Suiter Swantz Intellectual Property, 2020). A legislator would vote from their seat by setting a corresponding switch. Setting the switch completed an electrical circuit that caused the typeset characters that correspond to the vote to print on a roll of chemically treated telegraph paper. This created a permanent, auditable record of the vote, a feature that has carried on in modern voting machines.

    In 1892, the first mechanical voting machine for use in general elections was deployed in Lockport, New York, under state law. It was the Myers Automatic Booth (pictured below with patent drawing), patented by Jacob H. Myers in 1889. Massachusetts and Michigan put voting machines invented by



Top: Myers Automatic Booth patent drawing (Source: US415549A - Voting-machine - Google Patents), Bottom: Myers Automatic Booth photo (Source: www.instagrammernews.com)  

McTammany and Rhines, respectively, into service the following year. The Myers Automatic Booth enforced privacy with separate portals for entrance and exit (Keiper, 2021). A single voter entered the booth, made his or her selections behind a curtain, and moved a lever which opened the exit portal and reset the machine for the next voter. Once inside, the booth presented the voter with a matrix of push levers. Political parties were listed in the vertical column headings, and specific offices listed in the row labels. After moving the lever for the preferred party candidate in each office row, an internal mechanism incremented the vote count for that candidate and locked out all other selections for that office.  The counter system did not record the identity of any voter, thereby enforcing the secret ballot principle of anonymity.  In 1899, Congress amended the previous statute that restricted voting procedure in Congressional elections to a printed or written ballot. This cleared the way for adopting voting machines nationwide, and by 1929, voting machines like the Automatic Booth were in use in twenty-four states (Voting Machines, 1934). As the following photo reflects, variants of the Automatic Booth persisted well into the latter half of the 20th century.

 

U.S. Supreme Court nominee and U. S. Senate candidate G. Harrold Carswell calls for help from a poll worker as his voting machine sticks as he tries to vote, 1970 (Source: https://www.floridamemory.com/items/show/10042, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons)

The late 20th century saw steady improvements in automatic voting machine technology. Mechanical voting booths were replaced by more compact and efficient electronic systems. As the new century dawned, an historic piece of legislation accelerated the evolution, leading to the voting systems we use today.

In the period between 1988 and 2000, three types of electronic voting technologies gradually replaced mechanical voting machines (MIT Election Data and Science Laboratory, 2023). The first is the optical scanner that was rolled out in the 1960s. These systems optically scan a paper ballot on which the voter marks their choices in bubbles with a dark-colored pen or pencil in the same manner they would if they were taking one of the standardized tests of years past. The second technology, Direct-Recording Electronic (DRE) voting systems, first appeared in the 1970s. The original DREs replaced mechanical levers with push buttons and crude electrical memory. Modern DREs look more like laptop computers, some with touch screens. DREs are notable because the modern version includes a permanent artifact called a Voter-Verifiable Paper Audit Trail (VVPAT). Approximately one-third of all DREs used VVPATs in U.S. public elections as of 2016 (MIT Election Data and Science Laboratory, 2023). Unlike a cash register receipt, the VVPAT is not provided to the voter to prevent third parties from paying them for their vote. Instead, it provides a crucial paper trail for the recounts that are increasingly common in present-day elections. The third electronic technology was instrumental in changing the way Americans vote after 2000: punch cards.

Proliferated by IBM in the 1920s, punch cards recorded a voter’s selections when he or she pushed a button that perforated the paper at the location corresponding to the preferred office and candidate.  The resulting pattern of holes passed light or electric current to record the votes in memory. American adults over the age of 40 may recall the tumultuous recount in Florida to conclude the 2000 presidential election. Punch cards with partially punched holes, the so-called “dimpled and pregnant chads,” were painstakingly examined by election officials trying to determine the voter’s intent. The U.S. Supreme Court ultimately decided the race, and faith in the election system was shaken. To restore faith, Congress passed the Help America Vote Act (HAVA) in 2002. HAVA had a profound impact on voting technology development. First, it phased out mechanical and punch card voting machines in national elections (MIT Election Data and Science Laboratory, 2023). In addition, HAVA mandated that voting machine manufacturers accommodate voters with disabilities in their designs. Lastly, HAVA established the Voluntary Voting System Guidelines (VVSG), a set of standards for functionality, accessibility, and security of voting systems (United States Election Assistance Commission, 2023). Version 2 of the guidelines were approved in 2021.

The Votronic DRE (pictured below) is an example of a VVSG-compliant voting system for the HAVA era.  Chat GPT describes the modern DRE system architecture as follows:

 

Votronic VVPAT DRE (Source: Douglas W. Jones, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons)

At its core is an embedded microcontroller or processor running a real-time operating system (RTOS) or hardened Linux variant. The user interface—typically a touchscreen LCD or tactile keypad—connects through an input controller to capture voter selections. Each input triggers a digital event processed by the control logic, which validates the ballot structure loaded from secure, encrypted memory. Once the voter confirms their selections, the system commits the encrypted vote data to non-volatile storage (such as flash memory) and, in many systems, prints a VVPAT. Power conditioning circuits ensure stable operation under variable load, while hardware security modules (HSMs) and cryptographic chips manage digital signatures and encryption keys. Communication interfaces—USB, optical scanners, or secure network ports—are strictly controlled to prevent unauthorized access. After polls close, voting data is exported via cryptographically signed files.

    It’s clear that today’s system of electronic voting under the HAVA VVSG with a secret ballot has increased confidence in the U.S. election system. But fraud, however rare, remains a threat to that confidence. Indeed, there are documented cases of election fraud throughout U.S. history. The presidential election of 1844 is a notorious example. In that year, Democratic candidate James Polk defeated Republican Henry Clay in the state of Louisiana by 699 votes. The victory was sealed in Plaquemines Parish, where Polk prevailed by 990 votes. The problem was that in 1840, there were only 538 eligible voters in the parish (Wikipedia, 2025). The 2020 presidential election resurrected the specter of fraud as egregious as what took place in 1844. 2020 fraud allegations centered on an electronic voting system produced by Dominion Voting Systems, now owned by Liberty Vote (National Public Radio, 2025).  In the past five years, research by independent and objective groups at the state and federal level has disproven the Dominion allegations, which included deleting and flipping votes (CISA, 2020). Despite this, the Dominion experience has changed the course of voting technology development in the U.S. For the foreseeable future, states will rely on auditable paper voting records like the VVPAT. Voting systems designed to boost turnout, namely, voting remotely by mobile device, are unlikely to be widely adopted due to security concerns.

References

(1934). In J. P. Harris, Election Administration in the United States (pp. 247-282). Brookings Institution Press. Retrieved from https://www.nist.gov/system/files/documents/itl/vote/chapter7.pdf?utm_source=chatgpt.com

American History Central. (2025). The Presidential Election of 1788–1789 and the First Electoral College. Retrieved from American History Central: https://www.americanhistorycentral.com/entries/presidential-election-1789/

CISA. (2020, November 12). Joint Statement from Elections Infrastructure Government Coordinating Council & the Election Infrastructure Sector Coordinating Executive Committees. Retrieved from America's Cyber Defense Agency: https://www.cisa.gov/news-events/news/joint-statement-elections-infrastructure-government-coordinating-council-election-infrastructure

Henry Ford Museum of American Innovation. (2025). Patent Model of Edison's Electrographic Vote Recorder and Register, His First Patent, 1869. Retrieved from The Henry Ford: https://www.thehenryford.org/collections-and-research/digital-collections/artifact/251711?utm_source=chatgpt.com#slide=gs-183108

Keiper, F. (2021, December 15). 1911 Encyclopædia Britannica/Voting Machines. Retrieved from WikiSource: https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/1911_Encyclop%C3%A6dia_Britannica/Voting_Machines?utm_source=chatgpt.com

LegalClarity. (2025, August 19). What Is a Secret Ballot and How Does It Protect Voters? Retrieved from LegalClarity: https://legalclarity.org/what-is-a-secret-ballot-and-how-does-it-protect-voters/

LegalClarity. (2025, August 9). Why Was the Secret Ballot Introduced in the 1920s? Retrieved from LegalClarity: https://legalclarity.org/why-was-the-secret-ballot-introduced-in-the-1920s/

MIT Election Data and Science Laboratory. (2023, April 21). Voting Technology. Retrieved from MIT Election Data and Science Laboratory: https://electionlab.mit.edu/research/voting-technology

National Public Radio. (2025, October 9). Dominion, the voting tech company at the center of false 2020 claims, is sold. Retrieved from National Public Radio: https://www.npr.org/2025/10/09/nx-s1-5569817/dominion-voting-liberty-vote-false-claims

Reich, J. (2016, February 11). Thomas Edison's First Patented Invention Was An Electric Voting Machine. Retrieved from Tech Times: https://www.techtimes.com/articles/132791/20160211/thomas-edisons-first-patented-invention-could-have-drastically-changed-u-s-history.htm?utm_source=chatgpt.com

Suiter Swantz Intellectual Property. (2020, June 1). Thomas Edison's Electric Vote Recorder. Retrieved from https://suiter.com/thomas-edisons-electric-vote-recorder/?utm_source=chatgpt.com

United States Election Assistance Commission. (2023, June 7). Help America Vote Act. Retrieved from United States Election Assistance Commission: https://www.eac.gov/about/help_america_vote_act.aspx

Wikipedia. (2025, October 26). List of cases of electoral fraud in the United States. Retrieved from Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cases_of_electoral_fraud_in_the_United_States

 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Ingenuity is Timeless

Cooking in 2050: A Journey Through Futuristic Culinary Tech

Disruption in Data Center Design Part III: The Disruptor