Never Lost Again: Closing the Gaps in Transoceanic Flight Tracking After MH370
On March 7, 2014, Malaysian Airlines Flight 370 (MH370), a
Boeing 777-200ER, disappeared enroute from Kuala Lumpur to Beijing with 239 passengers
and crew on board
MH370 is not just a tragedy. It’s 239 tragedies. A hidden
dimension is that on this transoceanic flight, at the moment the passengers
realized something was terribly wrong, they had no means of quickly reporting
the situation to their loved ones or the authorities before disaster struck. On the other hand, the authorities lacked systems
for accurate, reliable telemetry from the aircraft to assess the nature of the
emergency. The flight data and cockpit voice recorders are sealed within the
aircraft fuselage, inaccessible during flight. Between departure and landing,
solutions are now available to improve our ability to track and directly
communicate with passengers on transoceanic flights during emergencies. In
recounting the science behind the search, this post explores those solutions and
how the legacy of MH370 may help break down the barriers to adopting them.
At the time of its disappearance, the MH370 Boeing 777-200ER
pictured below had myriad radio transmitters for communicating, navigating, and
sensing the flight environment.
Figure 1: The
Boeing 777-200ER Aircraft (Tail Number 9M-MRO) Used for Flight MH370 (Source: Kentaro
Lemoto from Tokyo, Japan, CC BY-SA 2.0
<https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.0>, via Wikimedia Commons)
Table 1
MH370’s Likely Installed Radio Frequency Transmitters
|
System |
Frequency |
Description |
|
Aircraft
Communications and Addressing Reporting System (ACARS) |
VHF (118-136 MHz) and
Inmarsat (see below) |
Delivery of flight
data, including status of on-board systems, altitude, heading, speed, and position,
to other aircraft and ground systems |
|
ATC Radios |
VHF (118-136
MHz) within line of sight, HF (2.8–22
MHz) beyond VHF range |
Cockpit voice
and data communications with air traffic control (ATC) |
|
Automatic Dependent
Surveillance-Broadcast (ADS-B) |
1090 MHz |
Reports aircraft
flight data to ground and airborne receivers; Note: Aireon began providing
ADS-B service through Iridium NEXT satellites four years after the MH370
disaster |
|
Distance Measuring Equipment (DME) |
960–1215 MHz |
Navigation
aid that measures the aircraft’s distance from a ground station |
|
Emergency Locator
Transmitters (ELTs) |
121.5 MHz and 406 MHz |
Broadcasts a beacon in
the event of a crash |
|
Inmarsat Classic Aero Service |
L-band
(1.5–1.6 GHz for uplink and 1.6–1.7 GHz for downlink) |
A commercial satellite
communication (satcom) service from Inmarsat used for Beyond-Line-of-Sight
(BLOS) phone and data communications (including ACARS) by and transoceanic
flights and ships at sea |
|
Radio Altimeter |
4.2 – 4.4 GHz |
A type of radar that
measures height above ground level at low altitudes |
|
Secondary Surveillance Radar (SSR) Transponder with Traffic Collision
Avoidance System (TCAS) |
Interrogation:
1030 MHz Response:
1090 MHz |
Reports
aircraft position, altitude, and identification when interrogated by ATC
radar; TCAS interrogates nearby aircraft transponders for collision avoidance |
|
X-Band Weather
Radar |
8-12 GHz |
Detects turbulence and
bad weather ahead of the aircraft |
Source: ChatGPT, based on the known systems installed on
Boeing 777-200ER aircraft and publicly available information, 2024.
In one of the many mysteries of MH370, the key systems in
the table above that allow authorities to track the aircraft went offline a
short time into the flight. ACARS messaging was disabled at 01:06 Malaysia Standard
Time (MYT), approximately one hour after takeoff
Records show that MH370’s SDU transmitted a network logon
request to the Inmarsat network at midnight MYT, approximately thirty minutes prior
to departing Kuala Lumpur
Table 2 Log of
MH370 SDU Messages Exchanged with Inmarsat Network
|
Time (MYT) |
Message |
|
00:41 |
Seventeen ACARS messages
exchanged prior to leaving the ground, and three more prior to 01:07 MYT |
|
01:07 |
Final ACARS message sent, last secondary radar contact
with MH370, satellite link goes down, possibly after an SDU power outage |
|
02:03 |
Ping from the network to MH370 goes unacknowledged |
|
02:05 |
Second ping from the network to MH370 goes unacknowledged |
|
02:25 |
MH370 SDU logs onto the Inmarsat network |
|
02:39 |
Ground to aircraft phone call acknowledged, unanswered |
|
03:41 |
Ping acknowledged |
|
04:41 |
Ping acknowledged |
|
05:41 |
Ping acknowledged |
|
06:41 |
Ping acknowledged |
|
07:14 |
Ground to aircraft phone call acknowledged, unanswered |
|
08:11 |
Ping acknowledged |
|
08:19 |
MH370 SDU logs onto the Inmarsat network after the aircraft’s
fuel is exhausted, auxiliary power unit (APU) deploys, and power is restored |
|
09:15 |
Ping unacknowledged |
on land or ditching in open water. Given the range and cruising speed of the Boeing 777 at altitude, the potential search area was enormous. Fortunately, there was additional information available that would help narrow the search.
More than a year after MH370 disappeared, in June 2014, the
Australian Transport Safety Bureau (ATSB) released an investigative report
BTO represents the round-trip time between initializing a
ping at the GES in Perth to receiving an acknowledgement from the aircraft
through the satellite relay
Figure 2:
Geospatial relationship between satellite and aircraft
earth, the location of which is defined by an angle Phi
measured from the center of the earth. Here, the earth is assumed to be a
perfect sphere. The great circle comprises all points on the sphere that are a
distance DSA from the satellite. Our knowledge of the last
known position and heading of MH370 from radar information, combined with the
nominal cruising speed of the Boeing 777-200ER at altitude (Zweck cites 905
km/hour at 35,000 ft), precludes the portion of the great circle that is on the
opposite side of the planet, and reduces it to one of a family of ping arcs
featured in news reports of the disaster investigation. Each BTO telemetry
point generates a separate ping arc. Zweck introduces a Concatenation of
Geodesics Model with a so-called ping arc equation enforcing the condition that
given a known starting point and constant altitude and velocity, MH370 must
cross each ping arc at the time corresponding to each BTO telemetry point. The
equation’s derivation is too long to restate here, and the reader is encouraged
to review Zweck’s paper for details. Suffice it to say, the model stitches
together the aircraft’s course by joining (concatenating) angles Phi(n) that
connect the BTO telemetry points on each ping arc. Sources of uncertainty in
the Concatenation of Geodesics Model are three-fold: aircraft speed, altitude,
and the angle to the next ping arc BTO telemetry point, Phi(n+1), where n
is an index. In addition, the model does not consider BFO telemetry. Because of
this, it cannot resolve an ambiguity in MH370’s heading. In other words, the
heading angle is the argument of a trigonometric function that has two
solutions, depending on its sign (positive or negative). Heading ambiguity
early in the investigation fueled media conspiracy theories. In the 2023
Netflix documentary MH370: The Plane that Disappeared, aviation
journalist Jeff Wise describes how he embraces the theory that MH370 fell
victim to an elaborate Russian hijacking plot and travelled north along
the ping arcs to a clandestine landing in Central Asia. Intriguing, but false,
as the next section will show.
BFO is the difference between the frequency of the ping
radio signal that the GES transmits, and the frequency of the acknowledgement that
the aircraft returns through the satellite. BFO is caused, in part, by the
Doppler shift of radio signals from the aircraft moving relative to the satellite
platform. Fundamentally, Doppler shift dFUP at BFO telemetry
point n is expressed as:
where c is the speed of light, Rsat is
the distance of the satellite from the center of the earth, f is the
frequency of the signal transmitted by the aircraft, and vao is
the component of the aircraft’s velocity orthogonal to the vector of its
position on the ping arc
Figure 3: Graphic
of Burst Frequency Offset (BFO) Contributing Factors in the Investigation of
Malaysia Airlines Flight 370 (Source: AHeneen, licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0
International license, https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/deed.en,
via Wikimedia Commons)
Doppler shift compensation in the SDU and the satellite. However,
the compensation is imperfect because it’s based on an idealization of the
satellite’s orbit. In considering BFO, SWG
had to account for the actual orbit of the Inmarsat satellite, which means
understanding the difference between geostationary and geosynchronous
orbit. Doppler shift compensation in the SDU is based on a geostationary orbit.
It’s a theoretical orbit where the satellite remains stationary above the
equator and moves in perfect tempo with the earth, i.e., zero relative velocity.
The actual orbit is geosynchronous, where the satellite returns to the same
point in the sky at the same time, every day. This is because the earth is an
oblate spheroid, slightly flattened at the poles and bulging at the equator due
to the relentless tug of the moon’s gravity.
This causes the plane of the orbit to tilt slightly away from the
equator. Consequently, the projection of the geosynchronous orbit on the
surface of the earth is not a point, but, in this case, a teardrop-shaped curve
known as an analemma
Zweck’s modified Concatenation of Geodesics model begins
with the same family of ping arcs. MH370’s speed on each ping arc is constant,
but in this model, the speed is initially unknown
Figure 4: A
Spherical Coordinate System
azimuth angle Theta. Zweck defines a moving coordinate frame for the aircraft and the satellite in the spherical coordinate system. Next, he derives the following equation that compares the Doppler shift dFUP from the BFO telemetry point on the current ping arc to a new analytical expression for the Doppler shift between the aircraft and the satellite that is moving counterclockwise relative to the center of the earth along the teardrop-shaped orbit discussed earlier:
(2)
where Rsat(n) is the distance of the
satellite from the center of the earth at telemetry point n, RA
is the constant distance of the aircraft from the center of the earth, and vsat(n)
is the satellite’s velocity orthogonal to the position vector Rsat(n).
Examining (2) reveals that dFUP is dependent on elevation
angle Phi(n) and azimuth angle Theta(n). This eliminates
the ambiguity in MH370’s heading in the first model. Computing this modified
Concatenation of Geodesics model with the satellite orbit propagating
counterclockwise reveals that MH370 was indeed headed south.
As an epilogue to the story, the SWG’s analysis, as
explained by Zweck, wasn’t enough to locate the wreckage of MH370 in the
Southern Indian Ocean by January 2018
The Inmarsat Classic Aero Service uplink from MH370 was
relayed to the GES in Perth by Inmarsat-3 F1. Launched in 1996
Table 3:
Active Inmarsat Satellites with L-Band Classic Aero Service as of March 2014
|
Satellite |
Location/Longitude (Degrees) |
Reference |
|
Inmarsat-2 F2 |
Western Pacific Ocean/98W |
|
|
Inmarsat-3 F1 |
Indian Ocean/64.5E |
|
|
Inmarsat-3 F2 |
Atlantic Ocean/55.4W |
|
|
Inmarsat-3 F3 |
Western Pacific Ocean/110W |
|
|
Inmarsat-3 F4 |
Atlantic Ocean/54W |
|
|
Inmarsat-3 F5 |
Atlantic Ocean/54W |
|
|
Inmarsat-4 F1 |
Central Pacific Ocean/178.2E |
|
|
Inmarsat-4 F2 |
Eastern Pacific Ocean/143.44E |
|
|
Inmarsat-4 F3 |
Western Atlantic Ocean/97.65W |
|
|
Inmarsat-4A F4 (Alphasat I-XL) |
Central Africa/25E |
|
over the Eastern Pacific Ocean at 143.44 degrees east longitude.
Launched in 2005, its L-band antenna, at the time, was capable of projecting over
200 narrow radio spot beams and 19 wide spot beams on the earth
(a)
(b)
Figure 5: (a)
Inmarsat-4 F2 Regional Spot Beam Number 18
clearly overlap in the
region of MH370’s last radar contact. It’s therefore plausible that at the
time, the Classic Aero Service logon request from MH370’s SDU was received and
processed by both satellites. The lack of any Inmarsat telemetry from other
satellites suggests that the network is configured to prioritize the uplink
with the greatest margin and drop the others. Hence, the only available
telemetry was from Inmarsat-3 F1. With BTO and BFO telemetry from both
satellites, a means of accurately and unambiguously geolocating MH370 at each
ping time would have been possible.
The technique of geolocating a moving radio emitter with two
or more receivers stems from the Long-Range Navigation (LORAN) system, first developed
in the early days of World War II
Figure 6: Basic
Hyperbolic Navigation Diagram (Source: Keith Tyler at English Wikipedia, Public
domain, via Wikimedia Commons)
towers, a primary and a
secondary (A and B in (a), above). The aircraft’s pilots know the distance
between the towers. The primary tower broadcasts a sequence of navigation pulses
at a known pulse duration and frequency. Upon receiving the primary tower’s
pulse sequence, the secondary broadcasts its own sequence after a short
processing delay, the magnitude of which is stored in the aircraft’s receiver.
The aircraft receives the pulse sequences from each tower and measures the time
delay between each pair of primary and secondary tower pulses in the sequence.
This is known as the Time Difference of Arrival (TDOA). TDOA is proportional,
by the speed of light, to the difference in the aircraft’s distance from each
tower. The difference can occur at an infinite number of locations between the
towers. For instance, if the calculated difference is 100 km, the aircraft
could be 50 km from each tower, or 25 km from one tower and 75 km from the
other, and so on. The locus of constant difference (100 km in this example) forms
a hyperbola called an isochrone that extends above and below a straight
baseline between the towers, as shown above. Measure a different TDOA, and
another hyperbola results, some distance from the first one. This leads to a
pattern of hyperbolae centered on the baseline, as shown. If the aircraft
repeats the process with a different pair created by a third tower, the two
sets of hyperbolae will intersect. The hyperbola that the aircraft is currently
flying on (which is known from the TDOA measurement and the tower pulse
sequence information) intersects with the hyperbola from the measurement with
the different pair of towers. The hyperbolae intersect in two places, showing
two points where the aircraft could be located. Like the ping arcs discussed
above, one possible location can be eliminated with information from a
navigation map, or another source. Recall from the discussion of Zweck’s models
above that because the aircraft is moving relative to the towers, there is a
Doppler shift in the frequency of the pulse sequences that it receives. This
allows the aircraft receiver to measure the Frequency Difference of Arrival
(FDOA) in addition to the TDOA. FDOA measurements result in sets of ellipsoidal
curves known as “isodops.” They overlay hyperbolic isochrones at roughly right
angles, thereby improving emitter geolocation accuracy. Had the SDU signals
from MH370 been received by Inmarsat-3 F1 and Inmarsat-4 F2, SWG could have
geolocated the aircraft using this process with the roles reversed. The
Inmarsat satellites are the receivers, MH370 is broadcasting pulses, and all
platforms are moving. The technique for geolocating an emitter when all
platforms are moving was perfected in the early 1970s. The key is applying the
Cross Ambiguity Function (CAF), a generalization of a cross-correlation
technique, to calculate the TDOA and FDOA at any time with moving receivers
In closing, for passengers to board future transoceanic
flights with confidence that they’ll never be lost again, there are near-term
opportunities and barriers. Two technologies are emerging that present
opportunities. The first is Direct to Device (D2D) satellite communications.
The second is Black Box Telemetry Streaming via satellite. Both are poised to
enter service, but regulatory barriers persist.
Today, there is a high tide of activity in the market for
D2D services from low earth orbit (LEO) satellite constellations. In April 2023,
AT&T announced a successful call with an unmodified cell phone using the
AST SpaceMobile network
Table 4: Link
Budget Excerpt for a Cell Phone on Board a B777-200 to a Starlink Satellite
|
Parameter |
Value |
Units |
Comments |
|
Phone
Output Power |
-6.99 |
dBW |
|
|
Phone Antenna Gain |
2.00 |
dBi |
Source: ChatGPT, most cell phone antennas have
modest gain between 0dBi to +2dBi. |
|
Phone
Antenna Losses |
-0.50 |
dB |
Typical
for consumer RF electronics |
|
Phone EIRP |
-5.49 |
dBW |
Phone’s equivalent isotropic radiated power after
adding the antenna gain and losses to the output power. According to ChatGPT,
cell phones generally transmit at power ranging from 0.1 mW to 200 mW. -5.49
dBW is about 180 mW. |
|
Path
Loss |
-158.0 |
dB |
This
is the attenuation that occurs when the signal travels 993 km to a Starlink
satellite that is 30 degrees above the horizon, 550 km above the earth. It’s
a function of the signal frequency, 1.9 GHz, which is T-Mobile’s mid-band
spectrum used for Starlink (Source: https://www.androidauthority.com/t-mobile-starlink-satellite-connectivity-3207661/).
|
|
B777-200 Cabin & Window Losses |
-18.00 |
dB |
Source: Hurst, 2008. |
|
Polarization
& Antenna Pointing Losses |
-0.35 |
dB |
|
|
Received Power |
-181.8 |
dBW |
This is the signal strength at the Starlink receiver
after adding the losses to the phone EIRP. |
antenna, receiver, and signal processing, are left out for brevity.
With the received power listed above, the budget shows that passengers can
successfully connect to Starlink in these conditions, albeit at a low data
rate, about 150 kilobits per second. As a result, practical communication in
most conditions would be limited to text messaging. Although the technology permits
passengers on future transoceanic flights to send D2D text messages in an
emergency, the current airline policy does not. The long-standing claim is that
cellular telephony interferes with aircraft communications. Note that this has
never been definitively proven. Despite this, paragraph (b)(5) of 14 CFR 91.21
authorizes the airlines to restrict cell phone use at their discretion
The prospect of geolocating wayward aircraft with TDOA and
FDOA measurements from two or more Inmarsat satellites was discussed
previously. In the aftermath of MH370, Inmarsat has been working on another improvement.
Two months after MH370’s disappearance, Inmarsat proposed a new application of
the successor to the Classic Aero Service, Swift Broadband
Author’s Note: The author is grateful to G.E. Cameron for
his contribution to this post.
References
Brokers, S. (2024). Inmarsat-4 F2 at 64° East.
Retrieved from Sky Brokers:
https://sky-brokers.com/satellite/inmarsat-4-f2-at-64-east/
Engebretson, J. (2023, April 25). A Whole New
Market? AT&T Demos Satellite Connectivity with an Unmodified Cell Phone.
Retrieved from telecompetitor:
https://www.telecompetitor.com/a-whole-new-market-att-demos-satellite-connectivity-with-an-unmodified-cellphone/
Frost, E. (2024, 6 14). New Underwater Sound
Signals May Finally Solve the MH370 Mystery. Retrieved from Sciinsider:
https://sciinsider.com/2024/06/14/new-underwater-sound-signals-may-finally-solve-the-mh370-mystery/
Hurst, K. a. (2008, 8). Path Loss From a Transmitter
Inside an Aircraft Cabin to an Exterior Fuselage-Mounted Antenna. IEEE
Transactions on Electromagnetic Compatibility, 50(3).
Infosatellites. (2010). Satellite Tracking,
Prediction and Informations about Objects in the Sky. Retrieved from
Infosatellites: www.infosatellites.com
Kadri, U. (2024, 5 2). Underwater acoustic analysis
reveals unique pressure signals associated with aricraft crashes in the sea:
revisiting MH370. Scientific Reports, 14(10102). Retrieved from
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-024-60529-1
Krebs, G. D. (2023, 1 14). Inmarsat-3 F1, 2, 3,
4, 5. Retrieved from Gunter's Space Page:
https://space.skyrocket.de/doc_sdat/inmarsat-3.htm
Krebs, G. D. (2024, 12 16). Alphasat (Inmarsat-4A
F4). Retrieved from Gunter's Space Page:
https://space.skyrocket.de/doc_sdat/alphasat.htm
N2YO. (n.d.). Inmarsat 4-F2. Retrieved from
N2YO.com: https://www.n2yo.com/satellite/?s=28899
Ottolini, E. (2024, 9 13). The satellite industry
cannot ignore the huge potential of D2D services. Retrieved from
SpaceNews:
https://spacenews.com/satellite-industry-cannot-ignore-huge-potential-d2d-services/
Pultarova, T. (2014, 7 10). Inmarsat: Arming
Against Tragedy. Retrieved from Space Safety Magazine:
https://www.spacesafetymagazine.com/space-on-earth/malaysia-flight-370/inmarsat-arming-tragedy/
SatBeams. (2020). Inmarsat-4F1. Retrieved
from SatBeams: https://www.satbeams.com/satellites?norad=33278
SatBeams. (2020). Inmarsat-4F2. Retrieved
from SatBeams: https://www.satbeams.com/satellites?norad=28899
Sigidwiki. (2021, 4 15). Sigidwiki.com.
Retrieved from Inmarsat Aero: https://www.sigidwiki.com/wiki/Inmarsat_Aero
Sky Brokers. (2021, 1). Inmarsat-3F1 (I3F1, IOR)
Satellite details. Retrieved from Sky Brokers:
https://sky-brokers.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/Inmarsat-3F1-Satellite-Footprint.pdf
Stein, S. (2018). A Primer on CAF Processing.
New Haven, CT, U.S.A.
Stupples, D. (2014, 4 9). MH370 should make us
rethink how we monitor planes. Retrieved from Phys.org.
Wikipedia. (2014). Mobile Phones on Aircraft.
Retrieved from Wikipedia:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mobile_phones_on_aircraft
Wikipedia. (2015, 12). Malaysia Airlines Flight
370 satellite communications. Retrieved from Wikipedia:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malaysia_Airlines_Flight_370_satellite_communications
Wikipedia. (2023, 3 5). Inmarsat-4 F3.
Retrieved from Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inmarsat-4_F3
Wikipedia. (2024, 11 14). LORAN. Retrieved
from Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LORAN
Wikipedia. (2025, January 29). Malaysia Airlines
Flight 370. Retrieved from Wikipedia:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malaysia_Airlines_Flight_370
Wikipedia. (n.d.). Inmarsat. Retrieved from
Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inmarsat#History
Zweck, J. (2015). Analysis of Methods Used to
Reconstruct the Flight Path of Malaysia Airlines Flight 370. Dallas, TX:
Department of Mathematical Sciences, University of Texas at Dallas.
_(3780278171).jpg)






Comments
Post a Comment