Keeping An Eye on Invisible Gas

     Natural gas is ubiquitous in the everyday lives of millions of Americans, supplying the energy we need for heating our showers, cooking our food, or warming our living space.  It’s also the feedstock for manufacturing numerous products.  In early February 2011, Albuquerque, New Mexico experienced a cold snap with low temperatures not felt in the region since 1971 (Haederle, 2011).  In its emergency preparedness, the community anticipated power outages and many frozen water pipes.  What wasn’t anticipated was the interruption of natural gas service from west Texas that was also affected by the weather.  As the gas pressure dropped in the conduits that supplied the state, vital economic activities, especially semiconductor manufacturing, ground to a halt.  The New Mexico cold snap is emblematic of how dependent on natural gas we have become, and the upheaval that ensues when supply is disrupted.  Beyond New Mexico, a nationwide gas dependence ostensibly comes with other risks besides natural disasters.

    Natural gas is methane formed from organic matter that has decayed underground over millennia (Newland, 2023).  The potential of natural gas as a source of heat and light has long been known in many cultures, from the Greeks who observed it burning from the ground at Delphi, to the native American tribes on the shores of Lake Erie in the early 17th century (American Public Gas Association, n.d.).  Natural gas distribution was commercialized in the United States in 1821 when William Hart’s functional gas well fueled the rise of the Fredonia Gas and Light Company in Fredonia, NY.  That was followed by the first city-owned distribution company, the Philadelphia Gas Works, which was founded in 1836 and operates to this day.

    There are approximately 56 more years of proven natural gas reserves worldwide, according to the U.S. Energy Information Administration.  New drilling techniques, especially hydraulic fracturing or fracking in shale deposits, have boosted production in North America in recent decades and brought prices down.  In the 2010s, natural gas prices were consistently below $5 per million Btu (Statista Research Department, 2023).  Although higher-priced than coal, this is significantly less than the price of petroleum products (such as heating oil) over the same period, which peaked at $12.5 per Btu in 2011 (Statista Research Department, 2023).  Worldwide distribution has expanded by chilling natural gas and transporting it overseas in the liquid phase.  In early 2023, the U.S. proposed liquid natural gas (LNG) as an alternative to Russian pipelines that supply Germany, a strategic partner in the conflict in Ukraine (Fluenta, 2019). Low unit cost, combined with more efficient extraction and distribution systems, have catalyzed the expansion of global natural gas utilities. In addition to favorable economics, combustion of natural gas adds less carbon dioxide to the atmosphere than burning coal and petroleum.  Because of this, natural gas is viewed by many as a means of easing the transition away from coal and oil in many markets.  The U.S. Energy Information Administration’s 2020 Residential Energy Consumption Survey revealed that 61% of U.S. households use natural gas for at least one service, predominately heating (Diamond, 2023).  The markets with the largest population of U.S. natural gas users reside in Midwest and Western states. 

Figure 1: Gas range with characteristic blue flame (Source: sfllaw, Wikimedia Commons, licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 2.0 Generic license https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.0/deed.en)

    Most consumers of natural gas in the modern era live a great distance from an extraction point.  This necessitates the network of steel pipelines that move gas under pressure across state lines to community distribution terminals administered by the local gas company (Team HomeServe, 2022).  These are known as city gates (natgas, 2013).  Gas enters residential buildings at the gas meter which measures customer consumption and steps down the distribution pressure to less than 1 pound per square inch.  Inside a building, gas moves through risers to appliances like water heaters, furnaces, and gas ranges.  This distribution system, though tested and reliable, is not perfect.  Widespread residential use of natural gas has led to leaks and in the worst cases, deadly explosions and fires.  Tremblay reports what is, sadly, a typical example of the incomprehensible power of an explosion caused by a residential natural gas leak (Tremblay, 2009):

The two-story, split-level, wood-frame house was 50 feet (15 meters) long by 30 feet (9 meters) wide. The grandfather and child had returned home at 1:40 p.m. and smelled a strange odor. Leaving his granddaughter sitting on a sofa in front of a large window in the living room, the man went to the basement to investigate when the explosion occurred, blowing the house apart and starting a huge fireball that engulfed the remains of the dwelling. The explosion also severely damaged five other homes or related structures nearby. A neighbor found the girl, who had been blown through the window, in the debris some 30 feet (9 meters) from the house.

Figure 2: Residential Gas Meter (Source: Wikimedia Commons, public domain)

    Compounding the danger is the fact that methane from leaking natural gas is a far more potent contributor to climate change than carbon dioxide.  The Environmental Protection Agency estimates that over 6 million metric tons of methane from natural gas infrastructure leaks into the atmosphere every year and the experts believe that to be an underestimate (MIT Climate Portal Writing Team, 2023).

    With natural gas infrastructure so widespread, it’s clearly difficult to continuously monitor and detect leaks.  Networks of unattended remote sensors would help for permanent installations such as pipelines, city gates, and buildings.  However, extraction sites tend to be transient and far away from population centers.  What’s more, many residential mishaps that cause leaks and catastrophes occur during maintenance activities, particularly those that involve digging near buried gas lines where sensors may not be installed.  The most effective solution may augment sensor networks on the ground with eyes in the sky. 

    In 2016, the Canadian company GHGSat launched the first small satellite in a commercial constellation designed to detect and geolocate methane leaks (Gauthier, 2020).  GHGSat created a wide-angle Fabry-Perot etalon that integrates with a 2U cubesat (roughly 20 x 20 x 20 cm).  Acting as an angle-dependent optical filter, the tuned etalon disperses different wavelengths of light in concentric rings.  Leaking methane absorbs certain wavelengths and forms a detectable contrast between rings.  In the company’s flight demonstrations, the compact sensor detected a plume of leaking methane from an extraction site in Turkmenistan.  Spatial resolution is on the order of 50 meters (McKeever, 2020).  This opens the possibility of pinpointing natural gas leaks in residential areas.  The recent joint venture between Apple and Globalstar for Direct to Cellphone service is a sign that the necessary network resources for getting leak detections to consumers on the ground quickly may not be far off.  Imagine if the grandfather in the previous example received multiple emergency calls and texts alerting him to the leak before he arrived home with his granddaughter.  Could a responsive gas leak early warning system save lives and keep methane out of the atmosphere in the future energy economy?

    This post recounts facts about natural gas distribution technology and commercialization in the U.S.   It also previews innovations that could improve safety and reduce its environmental impact.  It’s brief in comparison to our journey with natural gas.  It’s longer and remains unfinished.  In the decades ahead, world economies will weigh its many benefits with the consequences; the ones mentioned here and those that stay hidden.

References

Ahrens, M. a. (2018). Natural Gas and Propane Fires, Explosions, and Leaks: Estimates and Incident Descriptions. National Fire Protection Association.

American Public Gas Association. (n.d.). A Brief History of Natural Gas. Retrieved from https://www.apga.org/apgamainsite/aboutus/facts/history-of-natural-gas#:~:text=The%20first%20commercialized%20natural%20gas,light%20its%20streets%20with%20gas.

Diamond, K. a. (2023, March 23). Today In Energy. Retrieved from U.S. Energy Information Administration: https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=55940.

Fluenta. (2019, October 23). LNG – what is it and how is it made? Retrieved from Fluenta.com: https://www.fluenta.com/lng-what-is-it-and-how-is-it-made/.

Gauthier, J.-F. (2020). Monitoring Methane Emissions at Individual Oil and Gas Sites with Satellites: A New Tool at The Dawn of Global Transparency. Proceedings of the 2020 IEEE International Geoscience and Remote Sensing Symposium (pp. 3813-3816). IEEE. doi:10.1109/IGARSS39084.2020.9323989

Haederle, M. (2011, February 5). 30,000 Homes in New Mexico Lose Gas Service. The Los Angeles Times. Retrieved from https://www.latimes.com/world/la-xpm-2011-feb-05-la-na-gas-shortage-20110205-story.html.

McKeever, J. J. (2020, October 27). Spotting Mystery Methane Leaks from Space. IEEE Spectrum.

MIT Climate Portal Writing Team. (2023, July 17). How much does natural gas contribute to climate change through CO2 emissions when the fuel is burned, and how much through methane leaks? Retrieved from MIT Climate Portal: https://climate.mit.edu/ask-mit/how-much-does-natural-gas-contribute-climate-change-through-co2-emissions-when-fuel-burned.

natgas. (2013, September 20). Natural Gas Distribution. Retrieved from NaturalGas.org: http://naturalgas.org/naturalgas/distribution/.

Newland, D. (2023). Natural Gas 101: Pros & Cons. Retrieved from EnvironmentalScience.org: https://www.environmentalscience.org/natural-gas.

Statista Research Department. (2023, January 25). Average costs of fossil fuels for the electric power industry in the United States from 2005 to 2021. Retrieved from Statista: https://www.statista.com/statistics/183992/average-costs-of-fossil-fuels-for-us-electricity-generation-from-2005/#:~:text=The%20cost%20of%20fossil%20fuels%20in%20the%20electric,10.08%20U.S.%20dollars%20per%20million%20Btu%20for%20petroleum.

Team HomeServe. (2022, April 28). How Your Home's Natural Gas System Works. Retrieved from HomeServe Blog: https://www.homeserve.com/en-us/blog/home-improvement/natural-gas-system/.

Tremblay, K. J. (2009, May). Firewatch. NFPA Journal, 33-34.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Ingenuity is Timeless

Cooking in 2050: A Journey Through Futuristic Culinary Tech

Disruption in Data Center Design Part III: The Disruptor