TKA Tipping Point

      We take our knees for granted until the pain can no longer be ignored.  Between the large bones of the leg is one of the most complex joints in the body and one of the most common locations for injury and degenerative conditions as we age.  The total knee replacement procedure, known as Total Knee Arthroplasty (TKA) in medical terminology, has evolved to be a consistently successful and repeatable treatment for these common knee ailments.  A wide variety of knee prosthetics are indeed precision-engineered products.  It begs the question: are knee prosthetics and TKA approaching a tipping point?  Are they becoming durable and reliable enough to be considered as career-extending therapy for professional athletes, a performance enhancement for elite troops, or a even a boost for those seeking to look and feel younger?  To the promise of an end to pain, physical disability, and enhancing the human body, Tracinski asks this question (Tracinski, 2016):

Would people eventually feel pressure or temptation to remove healthy limbs or organs in favor of enhanced bionic replacements, and would that be a good thing?

We’ll examine this question in the context of the TKA Tipping Point.  First, a refresher on the anatomy of the knee and how it works.

Figure 1: The Knee Joint (Unaltered image: OpenStax College, CC BY 3.0 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0>, via Wikimedia Commons)


    The Arthritis Foundation offers a concise description of the anatomy of the knee joint (Arthritis Foundation, n.d.).  The knee is the nexus of two major bones of the leg: the femur or the bone of the upper thigh, and the tibia or shin bone (see image, right).  The patella or the kneecap protects the joint and aids the quadriceps in moving the tibia. Ligaments hold the joint together and promote stability. A pair of ligaments at the center of the knee joint are germane to the TKA discussion.  The anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) and the posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) prevent forward and backward displacement of the tibia, respectively.  In other words, they keep the tibia centered in the knee joint.   

This brings us back to the question:

Would people eventually feel pressure or temptation to remove healthy limbs or organs in favor of enhanced bionic replacements?

They may, if the prosthesis could reliably preclude the most common ailments of the knee joint without compromising comfort and range of motion over the average person’s lifetime.

    Many readers have experienced knee pain or know a person who has.  Pain is the result of injury, disease, or wear and tear in several areas.  According to the Mayo Clinic, the most common injuries are tearing of the ACL and the lateral/medial meniscus that serve as elastic shock absorbers.  In older patients, especially those who are overweight, osteoarthritis develops with age (Mayo Clinic, n.d.).  Osteoarthritis causes the elastic cartilage of the meniscus to break down.  Without meniscus cartilage, the bones come into contact, causing debilitating pain.  In many cases TKA is the recommended treatment.   

    Simply put, arthroplasty is surgery to repair or rebuild an injured or degraded joint, such as the knee or hip (Medical Dictionary - TheFreeDictionary.com, n.d.).  The procedure has its roots in the so-called interposition procedures conceived in the mid-19th century, where practitioners simply inserted (interposed) materials, such as pig bladder, in the joint (Song, 2013).  Pig bladders gave way to interposition with molded metallic components in the 1930s.  After World War II, the hinged knee prosthesis emerged.  These procedures offered marginal outcomes, with limited range of motion and early onset of failure, often due to loosening.  Fast forward to 1976, the dawn of modern TKA. Dr. Peter Walker and colleagues at the Hospital for Special Surgery in New York introduced the Total Condylar Knee (Levine, 2010).  The femoral component is polished chromium-cobalt alloy that mimics the curved lobes at the end of the femur, known as condyles.  The femoral component interfaces with the tibial portion comprised of polyethylene.  One of the most common polymers used by consumers, polyethylene is found in product packaging (low-density polyethylene or LDPE) and water bottles, to name a few.  The polyethylene portion sits atop a metallic platform with a post or stem that inserts into the tibia, along the axis of the bone.  A hemispherical polyethylene piece is bonded to the patella and assembles to the femoral and tibial parts.   There are myriad variations of this design on the market today, but many retain these basic features.  The Total Condylar Knee provides stability and range of motion, while resisting loosening.  The prosthesis components are shown below.

Figure 2: Total condylar knee prosthesis showing femoral and tibial components (Unaltered image by Graichen, annotated by   Mikael Häggström, M.D. CC BY 3.0 <https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0>, via Wikimedia Commons

    Newer total knee prostheses have features that extend the range of bending motion beyond the 90-100 degrees that was possible in the 1980s (Song, 2013).  One of these features is in the Mobile-Bearing prosthesis.  In this prosthesis, the polyethylene portion slides relative to the tibial pedestal, allowing for greater range of knee flexion (Foran, 2021).  In addition to the Mobile-Bearing prosthesis, there is the Bicruciate-Retaining prosthesis that preserves the ACL and PCL.  For many patients, this retains more of the natural knee stability and feel (Foran, 2021).

    Wear is a key factor in the service life of a modern knee prosthesis.  Wear between the bearing surfaces in a prothesis can generate metallic particles in the local tissue. The particles can cause an adverse reaction known as Metallosis (Vivegananthan, 2014).  To combat Metallosis, manufacturers have introduced a wear-resistant cross-linked polyethylene component with geometry that distributes friction forces over a larger bearing surface (Song, 2013).  Similar to Metallosis, some patients experience an allergic reaction to nickel in the alloy of the femoral prosthesis.  Oxidized zirconium, sold under the brand name Oxinium, has served as a substitute for nickel-containing alloys in recent decades (Kore, 2020).  It is produced by heating zirconium alloy in air which creates a hard metal oxide ceramic surface.  In a knee prosthesis, Oxinium has a lower coefficient of static friction as a bearing surface with polyethylene than cobalt chromium alloys. (Oxinium, n.d.)

    Research shows that cyclic shear loading of the cemented junction between bone and prosthesis (e.g. where one surface slides relative to the other) leads to loosening and ultimately revision surgery (Yang, 2010).  Yang, Zhang, and Arola evaluated bone-cement samples to shear cycles corresponding to four decades of use.  They found that shear strength increased with high-aspect-ratio texturing of the bone surface, a method referred to as “interdigitation” (Yang, 2010), therefore extending the life of the prosthesis.

    Combine these enhancements with the expanding number of TKA procedures performed in the United States.  Inacio et al. report that in 2012, over 700,000 TKAs were performed in the U.S.  This equates to 429 procedures per 100,000 people.  They project that number to increase to 712 per 100,000 by 2050 (Inacio, 2017).  It suggests an accelerating trend of innovation that builds on experience with a larger, statistically significant user base.  The tipping point may be evident when these innovations broach new markets, including professional sports.

    Mayo Clinic describes the athletic motions that put extreme tensile and torsional loads on the joint and lead to ACL and meniscus damage.  These include cutting from one direction to another, pivoting with the foot planted, direct impacts, and suddenly stopping (Mayo Clinic, 2022).  For a prosthesis to withstand these loads, the mating components would need to be stabilized by sizeable, stiff, elastic links such as elastomer springs or bands.  Intuitively, a joint with high-stiffness members would require much larger and stronger quadriceps and hamstring muscles to bend.  Superior stability comes at the expense of greater muscular exertion that only a handful of athletes may be able to manage.  It’s also possible that the future elite athlete’s knee prosthesis would operate with assistance from actuators outside of the body.

    In 2012, the now infamous athlete Oscar Pistorius, the so-called Blade Runner, competed for the first time, with non-amputees at the London Olympics.  Critics claimed that prosthetic legs would ostensibly give Pistorius and amputees like him an unfair advantage over runners with natural legs.  Later, Beck, Taboga, and Grabowski, proved that athletes competing in a sample 400-meter running event with prosthetic legs had no measurable advantage (Beck, 2022).  This research may have important implications for the future of TKA for elite athletes.  It may open the door for them to extend their careers without being disqualified from competing against their peers without prosthetics.

    We have explored the advances in TKA technology that have made the Total Condylar Knee prosthesis more comfortable, durable, and high performing.  While it’s clear that that TKA technology is steadily improving, the answer to the question posed in this discussion is an unsatisfactory “maybe.”  TKA may be at a tipping point where conditions are right for late-career professional athletes or elite troops to consider replacing failing knee joints.  Maybe that’s a good thing.  For the general public the signs point to a continued expansion of TKA as a reliable treatment for debilitating knee ailments and that is a good thing.  But, despite the dizzying progress, they don’t point to you and I embracing a prosthesis to eclipse our healthy joints.

References

Arthritis Foundation. (n.d.). Anatomy of the Knee. Retrieved from https://www.arthritis.org/health-wellness/about-arthritis/where-it-hurts/anatomy-of-the-knee

Beck, O. T. (2022, January 5). Sprinting with prosthetic versus biological legs: insight from experimental data. Royal Society Open Science, 9. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.1098/rsos.211799

Foran, J. a. (2021, September). Knee Replacement Implants. Retrieved from Orthoinfo: https://orthoinfo.aaos.org/en/treatment/knee-replacement-implants/

Inacio, M. P. (2017, Nov). Projected increase in total knee arthroplasty in the United States - an alternative projection model. Osteoarthritis Cartilage, 25(11), 1797-1803. doi:10.1016/j.joca.20

Kore, L. B. (2020, August 1). Oxidized Zirconium Total Knee Arthroplasty Implant Failure in a Patient With Knee Instability. Arthoplasty Today, 6(3), 552-555. doi:10.1016/j.artd.2020.06.015

Levine, D. (2010, April). The Hospital for Special Surgery 1972–1989; Philip D. Wilson, Jr., Eighth Surgeon-in-Chief. The HSS Journal, 6(10), 119-133. doi:10.1007/s11420-010-9162-3

Mayo Clinic. (2022, December 1). ACL Injury. Retrieved from https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/acl-injury/symptoms-causes/syc-20350738

Mayo Clinic. (n.d.). Knee Pain - Symptoms and Causes. Retrieved from https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/knee-pain/symptoms-causes/syc-20350849

Medical Dictionary - TheFreeDictionary.com. (n.d.). Arthroplasty. Retrieved from https://medical-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/arthroplasty

Oxinium. (n.d.). Retrieved from Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oxinium

Rawal, B. Y. (2016). Life Estimation of Knee Joint Prosthesis by Combined Effect of Fatigue and Wear. Procedia Technology, 23, 60-67. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.1016/j.protcy.2016.03.072

Song, E. S. (2013). The Evolution of Modern Total Knee Prostheses. In P. Kinov, Arthroplasty. IntechOpen. doi:10.5772/54343

Tracinski, R. (2016). The Future of Human Augmentation and Performance Enhancement. Retrieved from Real Clear Science: https://www.realclearscience.com/articles/2017/04/04/the_future_of_human_augmentation_and_performance_enhancement.html

Vaishya, R. C. (2013, December). Bone Cement. Journal of Clinical Orthopedic Trauma, 4(4), 157-163. doi:10.1016/j.jcot.2013.11.005

Vivegananthan, B. S. (2014, March 18). Metallosis in a total knee arthroplasty. BMJ Case Reports. doi:10.1136/bcr-2013-202801

Yang, D. Z. (2010, October). Fatigue of the bone/cement interface and loosening of total joint replacements. International Journal of Fatigue, 32(10), 1639-1649. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijfatigue.2010.03.005


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Ingenuity is Timeless

Cooking in 2050: A Journey Through Futuristic Culinary Tech

Disruption in Data Center Design Part III: The Disruptor