Concrete Answers to Climate Change

​Concrete Answers to Climate Change

 

If you’re at home right now, it’s likely that between you and Mother Earth sits a sturdy foundation of concrete.  This ubiquitous and versatile material is the bedrock of sidewalks, homes, and stadiums the world over.  It’s hard to imagine a future civilization without it.  However, climate researchers identify concrete manufacturing as a significant source of carbon dioxide, the catalyst of global warming.  How is the construction industry and its suppliers responding to concrete’s role in the climate crisis? In the absence of significant government policy, a transformation is occurring at the grass roots, and technology is playing a role.  To understand its impact on climate, let’s review the basics of concrete and how it’s produced around the world.  

Fundamentally, concrete is a solid mixture.  Its basic constituents are sand and gravel (aggregate) and a binder.  When activated by water, the binder causes the liquid aggregate slurryto cure and form a stiff, permanent structural member.  When concrete is poured into a wooden, metal, or composite mold or preform, it cures in myriad sizes and geometries.  Cultures in the Middle East have employed “artificial stone” by this process for thousands of years.  Perhaps the most impressive and enduring example from the ancient world is the Pantheon dome in Rome, erected in 113 – 125 A.D.  This free-standing concrete dome is over 140 feet (43 m) in diameter [1].  Builders experiment with different binders (also referred to as cementitious materials [5]) to this day, but one has dominated since 1824: Portland cement[1].  Patented by Joseph Aspdin, an English bricklayer, it is the standard for modern concretes.  Today’s recipe for Portland cement is as follows [1, 2]: 

• The key reactant, common limestone, is extracted from the earth and crushed to form a raw meal.  The raw meal may be mixed with other solids, discussed later.
• Raw meal is dried by pre-heating to 700 C.
• Heating of the raw meal continues in a cylindrical kiln.  At900 C, calcination converts calcium carbonate from the limestone to quicklime (calcium oxide) and, you guessed it, CO2.  For chemistry wonks, the reaction is: 

CaCO3 à CaO + CO2.

Next, the cylindrical kiln rotates, and at 2,640 F (1,450C)the quicklime product becomes pelletized.  The pellets are called clinker.  Grinding clinker and mixing it with gypsum creates Portland cement powder.

Portland cement is manufactured worldwide in manufacturing hubs and at construction sites.  China is the world’s largest producer, outputting over 4,000 million tons in 2017 [1].  Global cement production represents approximately 8% of the world's CO2 emissions, according to Chatham House.  It contributes more CO2 than aviation fuel (2.5%) and is not far behind the global agriculture business (12%) [1].  

​If manufacturing concrete contributes to climate change, then why not replace it with alternative materials?  The challenge is finding a carbon-free alternative that matchesconcrete’s favorable properties.  The table below compares some physical, thermal, and mechanical characteristics of concrete and a building material that many are familiar with: pine wood.   

Property

Value

Units

Compare To

Density [3]

2403

kg/m3

Softwood (such aswhite pine): 512

Thermal Resistance of 12-in Thick Poured Concrete[3]

0.38

m2 ℃/W

12 inches of a softwood (such as white pine): 2.64

Compressive Strength(Ultimate Strength when Loaded in Compression) 

30*

MPa

White pine: 

33 [5]

*15-cm cube of Grade M30 concrete, cured 28 days [4]

As the table indicates, the compressive strength of pine wood is comparable to concrete.  It’s also lighter weight per unit volume,a better thermal insulator, and more ductile.  Quick research also shows that they are comparable in price per square foot.  Despite these, wood products have the disadvantages of flammabilityand susceptibility to degradation from moisture.  The latest generation of wood-fiber and polymer composites may prove to be water resistant and non-flammable.  However, compositestend to be extruded rods and planks that cannot match the diversity of geometries that are possible with formed concrete. Concrete’s lack of ductility is overcome by embedding steel rebar prior to curing.  This is referred to as reinforced concrete [6].         

We’ve argued the merits of concrete as an affordable, plentiful, and versatile building material that is here to stay.  If so, are there solutions that curb CO2 in concrete production? Fischetti, Bockelman, and Srubar offer pathways to decarbonize every step of the concrete manufacturing process [2]:

Major Process Step

Pathways to Decarbonize

Mining and Crushing Limestone into Raw Meal

Use basalt or limestone produced with waste CO2

Preheating Raw Meal

Introduce equipment to capture CO2; eliminate fossil fuels for the kiln

Converting Raw Meal to Quicklime and Clinker

Lower the melting temperature of the quicklime by adding calcium fluoride or sulfate

Mix Ground Clinker with Gypsum to Form Portland Cement 

Change the recipe to replace a portion of the Portland cement with alternative binders that generate little or no carbon in manufacturing

Mix Cement with Aggregate and Water to Yield Concrete Slurry

Reduce carbon emissions in concrete mixing and transportation equipment

 

When a structure is demolished, ground waste concrete can absorb CO2 over time [2]. The Oregon Department of Transportation recently published an article on its work with so-called supplementary cementitious materials (SCMs) that displace Portland cement in its concrete supply [7].  ODOT worked with alternative mixes with SCMs including volcanic and fly ash, blast furnace slag, and ground glass.  The study reveals that alternative mixtures with up to 50% SCM reduced CO2 emissions in concrete manufacturing by greater than 25%.  However, the savings in carbon erodes if SCMs must be transported from distant markets.  Sentueq and Clayton point out that fly ash, for example, is a product of coal-fired power plants and is itself in the process of being phased out [8].  Even if distribution was expanded, blast furnace slag and fly ash could ostensibly supply at most 10% of global concrete production.  Regionally sourced SCMs such as volcanic pumice from nearby British Columbia are promising, but the supply tends to be inconsistent, thereby causing volatility in material prices.  Lastly, many of the alternative concretes surveyed take longer to cure than traditional mixtures, which can negatively impact construction costs.  An alternative that has the potential to eliminate carbon emissions is so-called bio concrete.  The North Carolina-based start-up BioMason harnesses microorganisms to bind a sand aggregate in a process similar to that which builds coral reefs [1].  The BioMason concrete cures in a few days at room temperature, without calcination.

When it comes to constructing a permanent structure like a residential home or apartment building, the stakes are high.  Not only do bio concretes and the other alternatives have to be structurally sound and cost competitive in the near term, they must also maintain integrity to the same degree as Portland-cement-based concrete over the life of the infrastructure.  In the housing market where safety is codified in law, there is little room for error.  Recently, homeowners in the state of Connecticut endured the nightmarish consequences when concrete manufacturers get it wrong.  Over 35,000 homes in the northeastern part of the state built between 1983 and 2015 have foundations with concrete produced by the JJ Mottes Concrete Company [9].  The Mottes aggregate contains the naturally occurring iron sulfide mineral pyrrhotite [10]. Over decades of exposure to oxygen and moisture, many of the foundations have crumbled, requiring total replacement at great cost to homeowners, insurers, and the state.

Concrete has been the foundation of our infrastructure for millennia.  In the decades to come, government regulation, international agreements, and market forces will move theconcrete industry to decarbonize. This may include Green Building codes that require concrete manufactured with dramatically lower CO2 emissions.  Promising alternative formulations and bio concretes are entering the marketplace. Alternative use will vary by geographic region, based on availability of raw materials.  But as the Connecticut case studyshows, alternatives must be well-understood and phased in with caution.  

References

1. Rodgers, L., Climate Change: The Massive CO2 Emitter You May Not Know About,https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-46455844, 12/17/2018.
2. Fischetti, M., Bockelman, N., and Srubar, W. V., Concrete Cure in Scientific American February, 2023.
3. Lindeburg, M.R., Mechanical Engineering Reference Manual for the PE Exam, 11th ed. Belmont CA: Professional Publications, Inc. 2001.
4. The Constructor, Compressive Strength of Concrete – Cube Test, Procedure, Results, https://theconstructor.org/concrete/compressive-strength-concrete-cube-test/1561/.
5. Hand Tool Essentials, Compressive Strengths for North American Softwoods – Compressive Strength of Popular Softwoods, https://handtoolessentials.com/blog/woodworking/compressive-strengths-north-american-softwoods/, 2021.
6. Wikipedia, Reinforced Concrete, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reinforced_concrete.
7. Oregon Department of Transportation, Cement Substitutes, https://www.oregon.gov/odot/climate/Documents/SCMs_InfoSheet-ODOTghginventory.pdf.
8. Sentucq, E., and Clayton, M., Institution of Structural Engineers Guidance, https://www.istructe.org/resources/guidance/beyond-portland-cement-low-carbon-alternatives/
9. Connecticut State Department of Housing, Crumbling Foundations, https://portal.ct.gov/DOH/DOH/Programs/Crumbling-Foundations, 2023.
10. King, H. M., Pyrrhotite, https://geology.com/minerals/pyrrhotite.shtml.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Ingenuity is Timeless

Cooking in 2050: A Journey Through Futuristic Culinary Tech

Disruption in Data Center Design Part III: The Disruptor